Will Your Homeowners Policy Protect Items in Storage?

Many Nashville homeowners turn to self-storage facilities when they need extra space for seasonal decorations, furniture during moves, or treasured family heirlooms. But here’s a question we hear frequently at Benton White Insurance: “Are my belongings protected by my homeowners policy when they’re stored off-site?”

The answer isn’t as straightforward as you might think. Let’s explore how homeowners’ insurance works with storage units and what Middle Tennessee residents need to know to keep their valuables protected.

The Basics: How Homeowners’ Insurance Works with Storage

Your homeowners insurance policy includes personal property protection that extends beyond your home’s four walls. This coverage typically follows your belongings wherever they go, including to storage facilities around Nashville and Middle Tennessee.

However, there’s an important catch: most policies limit off-premises coverage to just 10% of your total personal property limit. If you carry $50,000 in personal property coverage, only $5,000 might apply to items in storage. For many homeowners, this limitation creates a significant coverage gap.

What Your Standard Policy Typically Covers

Protected Scenarios:

  • Theft from your storage unit
  • Fire damage at the storage facility
  • Vandalism or malicious mischief
  • Certain weather-related damages
  • Accidental damage during transportation

Common Coverage Limits:

  • Usually 10% of your personal property coverage limit
  • Same deductible as your homeowners policy
  • Subject to your policy’s standard exclusions

Significant Gaps in Standard Coverage

While basic protection exists, several important exclusions could leave you financially vulnerable:

Flood Damage: Standard homeowners policies exclude flood damage, even in storage units. With Middle Tennessee’s history of flooding, this is particularly concerning for local residents.

Earthquake Damage: Tennessee sits near the New Madrid fault line, making earthquake coverage worth considering for stored items.

Pest and Rodent Damage: Insurance won’t cover damage from mice, insects, or other pests – a common problem in storage facilities.

Mold and Mildew: Tennessee’s humid climate makes this a real risk, especially in non-climate-controlled units.

High-Value Items: Expensive jewelry, electronics, art, and collectibles often have limited coverage under standard policies.

Smart Solutions for Better Protection

Choose Your Storage Facility Wisely

When selecting a storage facility in the Nashville area, prioritize:

  • Climate control – Essential in Tennessee’s humid climate
  • Security features – Gated access, surveillance cameras, and on-site management
  • Reputation – Research reviews and ask neighbors for recommendations
  • Insurance requirements – Some facilities require proof of insurance

Consider Insurance Enhancements

Personal Property Endorsements: These can increase your off-premises coverage beyond the standard 10% limit.

Scheduled Personal Property: For valuable items like antiques, jewelry, or electronics, scheduling provides comprehensive protection with no deductible.

Umbrella Policies: These provide additional liability protection if someone is injured at the storage facility.

Storage Facility Insurance vs. Your Homeowners Policy

Many storage companies offer their own insurance products, but these policies often provide minimal coverage and may not be as comprehensive as extending your homeowners protection. Before purchasing facility insurance, compare it carefully with enhancing your existing homeowners policy.

Protecting Your Investment: Best Practices

Documentation is Key:

  • Create a detailed inventory with photos
  • Keep receipts for valuable items
  • Update your insurance agent about high-value stored items
  • Review your coverage limits annually

Smart Packing Strategies:

  • Use moisture-absorbing products in humid Tennessee weather
  • Elevate items off the floor to prevent water damage
  • Choose sturdy, sealed containers over cardboard boxes
  • Avoid storing irreplaceable items like family photos (consider digital storage instead)

What to Do When Problems Occur

If your stored belongings are damaged or stolen:

  1. Contact law enforcement if theft is involved
  2. Notify your insurance agent immediately – don’t wait
  3. Document everything with photos and detailed lists
  4. Cooperate with the storage facility’s investigation
  5. Keep all receipts related to the incident

Why Middle Tennessee Residents Need Special Consideration

Living in Middle Tennessee presents unique challenges for storage:

  • Weather extremes from hot, humid summers to occasional severe storms
  • Flood risks in certain areas, particularly near rivers and creeks
  • Tornado season requires consideration of wind and hail damage
  • High humidity can damage sensitive items without climate control

Making the Right Choice for Your Family

At Benton White Insurance, we understand that every Nashville family’s storage needs are different. Whether you’re storing holiday decorations, business inventory, or family heirlooms, we can help you find the right balance of protection and affordability.

Don’t assume your current coverage is adequate – many homeowners discover their gaps only after experiencing a loss. A quick review of your policy with our experienced agents can identify potential issues and solutions before you need them.

Next Steps: Protecting Your Peace of Mind

Storage units offer convenience and extra space, but they shouldn’t create insurance headaches. With proper planning and the right coverage, you can store your belongings confidently, knowing they’re protected against life’s unexpected events.

If you have any questions about the insurance on your home and want to make sure you understand your coverage, you can call us at any time. At Benton White Insurance, we ask that you call us BEFORE you file a claim.  We can save you money and time.  – almost every time.  We can help you cut through all of that.

THANK YOU for your trust in what we do.  We’re here to help.  Let us help you if you have a claim. We will make it much easier on you for sure.

TEXT or CALL us at 615.377.1212 or EMAIL us at info@BentonWhite.com.  Also, on our website – BentonWhite.com, you can get more claim information and file a claim from the site.  Let us know how we can help you as we ‘earn’ your business!


This guide provides general information about insurance coverage. Specific policy terms, conditions, and exclusions vary by insurer and individual circumstances. Contact Benton White Insurance for personalized advice about your coverage needs.

Leave your comment